Why Comparing Daily Cash Value Growth With Daily Loan Interest Misleads
Setting a policy's daily cash value growth beside a policy loan's daily interest misleads in three ways. The growth happens with or without the loan, so the loan does not earn it. The fair test for a financing decision is the loan's interest against the other ways to pay. And daily growth is an average: dividends are credited yearly, while unpaid loan interest is generally added to the loan at the anniversary.
A presenter puts two numbers on the screen. The first shows how much the cash value of a participating whole life policy grows each day. The second shows how much interest a policy loan costs each day. The first number is larger, and the room goes quiet, because the conclusion seems obvious: the loan pays for itself.
It is a tidy picture. It is also wrong in three separate ways, and each one can cost a family real money over the years.
I see this comparison often, in seminars, in social media posts and in questions families bring to our first meeting. It is usually offered in good faith. The person showing it believes it. That is exactly why it deserves a careful answer instead of a quick dismissal.
Why does this matter? Because a family that believes its policy loan is free stops treating it like a debt. It stops paying the interest. It stops planning the repayment. And a debt that is never treated as a debt grows quietly, year after year, until it starts to crowd the very value that secures it. The policy did not fail. The arithmetic was simply misread.
The good news is that the correct reading is not complicated. Once you see what each daily number really measures, the comparison loses its power, and a much more useful question takes its place.
Let us take the comparison apart, one piece at a time.
What does the daily comparison claim?
It claims that because a policy's cash value grows by more each day than its loan costs in interest each day, the loan is effectively free, or even profitable. It treats the two figures as competing amounts on the same scale, so that subtracting one from the other shows what the owner gains by borrowing.
The claim usually comes in one of three forms. In the first, a slide divides the expected yearly growth of the cash value by the days in a year and does the same with the yearly loan interest. In the second, someone says, "Your cash value is growing every single day while you have the money in your hands." In the third, the loan is described as "paid for" by the policy's own growth.
All three forms share a hidden assumption. They assume that the growth and the interest are connected, that the first offsets the second, and that the owner keeps the difference.
There is a piece of truth inside the claim, and I want to name it plainly. A policy loan does not take money out of the policy. The insurer advances its own funds and holds your cash value as collateral, so the value stays where it was and keeps following the contract. That is a real and useful feature, and it is the reason the daily comparison sounds so plausible. How a policy loan is made and administered is explained on policy loans.
But the claim goes further than that truth allows. It turns a fact about where the money sits into a conclusion about what the loan costs. Those are two different questions, and the rest of this page separates them.
The daily version of the argument is a close cousin to a broader one, in which a dividend figure is set beside the loan rate. That broader comparison is examined on policy loan interest and dividends. Here we stay with the per-day framing, because it carries its own errors.
How is cash value actually credited during the year?
the cheapest coverage, for a while
What term life insurance does and does not do
- 01Coverage for a fixed period, usually ten to thirty years
- 02It pays if the insured dies within the term
- 03It pays nothing if the insured does not
- 04It has no cash value at any point
- 05It costs a fraction of permanent coverage
Not day by day, like interest on a savings account. A participating contract sets its guaranteed cash values at each policy anniversary, and dividends are generally credited once a year, at the anniversary. Between anniversaries, how a value is worked out depends on the contract. A daily growth figure is an average spread across the year.
Start with the guaranteed values. A participating whole life contract contains a table of guaranteed cash values, one for each policy year. Those values are fixed in the contract on the day it is issued. They do not depend on markets, provided the premiums are paid and the insurer meets its obligations. The table moves in steps, from one anniversary to the next. How to read it is explained on reading the cash value table.
Then the dividends. Each year the insurer's board may declare dividends on its participating policies, based on the results of its participating account. Dividends are not guaranteed. Yet the Canadian insurers we work with have paid them every year for generations, as you will see further down this page. In our method, each dividend stays in the policy and buys paid-up additions, which carry their own cash value and death benefit. Under most contracts, that happens once a year, at the anniversary, not a little each day. How additions work is set out on paid-up additions.
So what about the days in between? If you surrender a policy halfway through a policy year, the insurer must work out a value for that date. Many contracts describe a method for this, and the method belongs to the contract, not to a slide. That value between anniversaries is a calculation for a specific purpose. It is not a sign that interest is being credited to your policy every morning.
This is the third error in the daily comparison, and it is worth stating clearly. When someone divides a year's expected growth by the days in the year, they produce an average. The average is arithmetic. It is not how the contract credits value. The policy does not earn a small amount each day the way a deposit account does; it moves from one anniversary value to the next, and the dividend arrives once a year, if it is declared.
Two more points keep the picture honest. First, the expected growth used on the slide usually comes from an illustration's projected column, which assumes today's dividend scale continues. Dividends are not guaranteed; a lower dividend slows future growth but does not reduce cash value already credited. Second, early in a contract's life the growth can be small compared with the premiums paid, because the first years carry the heaviest costs. A single daily figure hides both of these facts.
The broader point, that "grows every day" needs the right meaning, is examined on how the participating account works and what markets change.
How does policy loan interest accrue and get added to the loan?
Interest accrues over the year on the amount borrowed, and contracts differ on how it is calculated. Under most contracts, interest that is not paid by the policy anniversary is added to the loan. From then on, the unpaid interest bears interest itself, so a loan left alone grows faster each year than it did the year before.
The Income Tax Act defines a policy loan as an amount advanced by an insurer to a policyholder in accordance with the terms and conditions of the policy. That definition, in subsection 148(9) of the Act, settles who lends. The insurer lends. The interest is paid to the insurer. It is not credited back to your policy, and it is not paid to you.
The rate is set by the insurer under the contract. Many contracts allow the insurer to change it within limits the contract describes. Some insurers calculate the interest in advance for the year, others in arrears, and others accrue it as time passes. That is why I suggest you never rely on a general description, including this one, for your own contract. Ask the insurer, in writing, how interest is calculated on your loan.
What most contracts share is the treatment of unpaid interest. If you do not pay the interest by the anniversary, the insurer generally adds it to the loan balance. This is called capitalizing the interest. Next year, interest is charged on the larger balance. The year after, on a larger one still. Contract wording varies, so read yours or ask the insurer to confirm.
Notice what this means for the daily comparison. On the slide, the daily interest figure is usually today's rate applied to today's loan, divided by the days in a year. It is a snapshot. But the loan does not stay the same size if the interest is not paid. Its daily cost rises each year as unpaid interest is added. The growth figure on the slide, by contrast, is often an average of the years ahead. The comparison sets a snapshot of one line beside an average of another.
The Autorité des marchés financiers explains the effect at the end of the road on its page about accessing the cash surrender value without cancelling your insurance: interest accrues on the borrowed amount, and if the insured dies before the loan is repaid, the insurer subtracts the amounts owed plus accrued interest from the amount of insurance payable. A daily figure on a slide never shows that line.
Whether you pay policy loan interest "to yourself" is a separate question, answered plainly on do you pay policy loan interest to yourself. The short answer is no: the insurer is the lender, and the interest is the insurer's.
Would the cash value grow the same way without the loan?
name the alternative, or there is none
The comparison that is actually honest
- 01The usual case compares an advance to an outside loan
- 02That holds only if you would have borrowed anyway
- 03If you would not have, compare it against paying cash
- 04Interest on an advance is paid to the insurer
- 05A comparison is incomplete until the alternative is named
In Canada, generally yes. Participating contracts are generally designed so that an outstanding loan does not change the dividend, and the guaranteed values follow the contract either way. The growth belongs to the policy whether or not you borrow, so the loan cannot claim it. This is the first and largest error.
Here is the statement we use on every page where loans and dividends meet. In Canada, participating contracts are generally designed the way Americans call "non-direct recognition": an outstanding policy loan does not change the dividend the contract receives. Equitable Life of Canada, a mutual insurer owned by its participating policyholders, states this in its own advisor material. Sun Life, Canada Life and Manulife, which are shareholder-owned companies, work the same way in our experience. We confirm the treatment in writing for every contract. Dividends are not guaranteed.
Now follow the logic. If the dividend is the same with or without the loan, and the guaranteed values are the same with or without the loan, then the cash value grows the same way with or without the loan. The growth was going to happen anyway. The loan did not create it and does not earn it.
So what does the loan add? It adds a debt. And the debt carries interest. The honest accounting of a policy loan has one new line, not two: a cost. The growth line was already there before you borrowed.
Consider a hypothetical owner with two identical policies, issued on the same day, with the same premiums paid and the same dividends declared. The owner takes a loan against one and not the other. At the next anniversary, both policies show the same cash value. One also shows a loan balance. The difference between the two contracts is not the growth. It is the debt.
That is why the phrase "the growth pays the interest" is misleading. Growth can make it easier to carry a loan, because the room between the cash value and the debt tends to widen when values rise. But it does not pay the interest. Only you pay the interest, or the insurer adds it to the loan. The question of whether growth continues while a loan is outstanding is answered on does cash value keep growing with a loan.
There is a practical consequence for how you read your statement. After a loan, the line that matters is the net cash value: the cash value minus the loan and any interest added to it. The cash value already credited stays credited. The net value is what shrinks when interest is left unpaid.
Why does a per-day number feel so convincing?
Because small numbers feel harmless and two numbers side by side invite subtraction. Dividing by the days in a year turns a large yearly cost into a tiny daily one, and placing it beside a slightly larger daily growth figure makes the gap look like a gain, even though the two figures measure different things.
There is a reason this framing travels so well. A yearly interest cost, written as a single number, gets attention. The same cost divided into daily pieces looks almost trivial.
The second effect is subtraction. When the eye sees two figures next to each other, it reads the difference as a result. If growth per day is larger than interest per day, the gap looks like money earned. But a gap between two numbers only means something if both numbers belong to the same calculation. Here they do not. One is the policy's growth, which happens anyway. The other is the loan's cost, which happens only because you borrowed.
The third effect is the calm of a daily figure. It suggests steadiness: a little in, a little out, every day, forever. Real contracts do not move that way. Values step forward at anniversaries. Dividends are declared once a year and are not guaranteed. Unpaid interest is added in a lump. A daily figure smooths away every one of those steps, and with them the moments when a family should be paying attention.
None of this means the person showing the slide intends to mislead. Most people repeat what they were taught. But a framing can mislead even when nobody means it to. That is why I suggest we judge the comparison by what it leaves out, not by who presents it. The same habit is useful for any statement heard in a seminar, as shown on seminar claims about participating policies, checked.
What is the fair comparison for a financing decision?
Set the policy loan's interest beside the cost of the other ways to pay for the same purchase: another lender, or cash you already hold. Use the same amount, the same period and the same repayment plan. The policy's growth does not belong in this comparison, because it happens whichever way you pay.
This is the second error in the daily comparison, and it is the one with the most practical value. When you decide how to pay for a vehicle, a renovation or a piece of equipment, the real question is not "does my policy grow faster than my loan costs?" The real question is "which way of paying costs my family the least, and fits our plan?"
There are usually three choices. You can take a policy loan from the insurer. You can borrow from another lender, such as a line of credit or an instalment loan. Or you can pay with cash you already have. Each choice has a cost, and the costs can be compared fairly.
| Way to pay | What it costs | What else to weigh |
|---|---|---|
| Policy loan from the insurer | Interest at the insurer's rate, paid to the insurer | No outside credit decision, no imposed schedule, net values reduced until repaid |
| Loan from another lender | Interest at that lender's rate, paid to the lender | Credit approval, a fixed schedule, terms the lender can review |
| Cash already held | The return that cash would otherwise have earned | No debt, but the cash is spent and must be rebuilt |
Notice what is missing from the table. The policy's growth does not appear in any row. If your contract does not adjust dividends for loans, the policy grows the same way whether you take the policy loan, borrow elsewhere or pay cash. A line that is the same in every row cannot change which row is cheapest.
So a policy loan is not automatically the cheapest choice. Depending on the rates on the day, it may cost more than a secured line of credit. Its strengths are elsewhere: no credit application, no imposed schedule, and the freedom to slow repayment in a hard year. Those strengths are real. They are just not the same thing as being free. The full comparison of a policy loan with other credit is laid out on a policy advance and other credit, and the wider question of what a fair comparison must hold constant is examined on the comparison question.
There is also a tax side to a fair comparison. A policy loan is a disposition under section 148 of the Income Tax Act. When the proceeds of the loan, as the Act defines them, exceed the adjusted cost basis of your interest in the policy, the excess is included in income. Repayments of policy loans are added back to the adjusted cost basis. Whether any of this applies to your loan is a question for your accountant, who can read the insurer's figures for your contract.
Finally, a word on the rate gap itself. Some families believe that borrowing at a higher rate than they earn always loses money, and others believe it can never matter. Both views skip the volume of interest and the repayment period, which is the subject of earn 8 percent, pay 13 percent. I will not repeat that analysis here. The point for this page is narrower: the daily growth of the policy is not one of the rates in that comparison.
When does the loan grow faster than the value securing it?
When interest is left unpaid long enough. Unpaid interest is generally added to the loan at the anniversary, so the debt compounds. If the debt grows faster than the cash value securing it, the room narrows each year and the net cash value shrinks. On this point the critics are right: the risk is real, and you control it.
The daily comparison hides this risk because it shows today's loan, not the loan ten years from now.
Consider a hypothetical owner who takes a loan equal to a modest share of the cash value and pays no interest. Each anniversary, the unpaid interest is added to the balance. In the early years, the cash value may grow faster than the loan, and the room between them may even widen. But the loan grows on a growing base. Over a long enough period, a loan left alone can close the gap.
How fast that happens depends on three things: the loan rate the insurer charges, the pace of growth in the cash value, and the size of the loan compared with the value. A young contract, a large loan, or a period when the dividend scale is lower can all bring the two lines together sooner than a slide suggests. Dividends are not guaranteed; a lower dividend slows future growth but does not reduce cash value already credited. The loan, meanwhile, keeps compounding if its interest is not paid.
If the debt ever reaches the cash value, the insurer gives notice. If nothing is done, the contract can end. Ending the contract is a disposition, and the gain above the adjusted cost basis can become taxable income in a year when no cash arrives to pay the tax. What happens in that case is set out on what happens if the policy lapses.
Here is the part I want every family to hear. This outcome has nothing to do with whether the daily growth figure was larger than the daily interest figure on the day of the loan. It has everything to do with whether the interest was paid and the loan repaid.
The credited value of the policy stayed credited in this story. What shrank was the net value, the part left after the debt. That distinction matters, and it is explained on could your policy's cash value go down.
Why does the daily framing discourage repayment?
conceded before anything is answered
What the critics get right
- 01Early cash value is low against the premium paid
- 02The commitment is long and costly to abandon
- 03Costs are not disclosed line by line
- 04A household without durable surplus has cheaper places to hold money
- 05The comparison usually offered is the wrong comparison
Because if the loan looks free, there seems to be no reason to repay it. The daily framing quietly removes the habit that makes policy loans work: treating the insurer's advance like any other debt, paying the interest each year and repaying the balance on a schedule the family sets and keeps.
This is, in my experience, the most expensive consequence of the daily comparison. Not the misunderstanding itself, but what people do because of it.
A family that sees the loan as costing nothing will reasonably ask, "Why repay?" The interest seems covered. The policy seems to be growing anyway. So the loan stays open, the interest is added to it each year, and the habit of repayment never forms.
Our approach runs the other way. Rule seven of Infinite Financial Sovereignty® is "Never pay cash." In practice, that means the premium is paid every year, the extra deposit option is maximized every year, dividends stay in the policy as paid-up additions, and policy loans are repaid from the family's cash flow on a schedule. The repayment is not optional decoration. It is what returns the borrowing room for the next purchase, and what keeps the net values of the policy growing.
A simple rule works for most households: repay a policy loan over a period you would accept from an outside lender for the same purchase. A vehicle you would finance over five years, you repay over five years. If a hard year arrives, the contract lets you slow down. That freedom is a safety valve, not a plan.
Review the loan once a year, at the anniversary, against the insurer's statement: the cash value, the loan balance with interest added, and the room between them. A family that does this will never need a daily figure to tell it how things stand. How a family runs that yearly review is described on the yearly review of a family financing system.
What does an honest version of the claim sound like?
It sounds less exciting and far more useful: "Your cash value stays in the policy while you borrow, and it keeps following the contract. The loan is a debt to the insurer. Its interest is a real cost. Compare that cost with your other ways to pay, and repay the loan on a schedule you keep."
The dishonest version and the honest version start from the same fact: borrowing against the policy leaves the value inside it. They part ways on what that fact means.
| What the daily comparison says | What is accurate |
|---|---|
| Your cash value grows every day | Guaranteed values step forward at anniversaries; dividends, not guaranteed, are generally credited once a year |
| The growth pays the loan interest | The growth happens with or without the loan; only you pay the interest, or it is added to the loan |
| The loan is free if growth beats interest | The loan's interest is a real cost; compare it with another lender or with cash |
| Interest is a small daily amount | Unpaid interest is generally added at the anniversary and then bears interest itself |
| There is no need to hurry repayment | Repayment on a schedule keeps the net values growing and the borrowing room available |
The honest version can still be said with warmth and confidence. Here is how I would put it to a family across the table.
"Your policy keeps doing its work while you use it. The guarantees in your contract do not stop because you borrowed, and in Canada an outstanding loan generally does not change the dividend. That is a genuine advantage. But the loan is a debt to the insurer, and its interest is the price of using the insurer's money instead of a lender's or your own. Let us compare that price with your other choices, and let us set a repayment plan you will actually keep."
That version sells no illusion. It also leaves no one surprised in ten years.
What should you ask the insurer before relying on any daily figure?
the commonest reasons it fails
Who this method does not suit
- A household whose income cannot carry an ordinary decade
- Anyone who may need the capital in the first several years
- Anyone who will not repay what they draw
- Anyone who does not actually want permanent coverage
- Anyone who cannot say what the contract is for
Five questions, in writing: how loan interest is calculated, when unpaid interest is added to the loan, how cash value is worked out between anniversaries, whether the loan changes the dividend on your contract, and how far the loan is from the cash value today and at the next anniversary.
Brochures describe products in general. Your contract describes your rights. Before you accept any daily comparison, ask the insurer to confirm these points in writing.
- How is interest on my policy loan calculated, at what rate today, and how can the rate change under my contract?
- When is unpaid interest added to the loan, and from what date does that added interest bear interest?
- How is my cash value worked out between policy anniversaries, if I need a value on a date in between?
- Does an outstanding loan change the dividend credited to my contract, and can you confirm that in writing?
- What are my cash value, loan balance and remaining loan room today, and what are they projected to be at the next anniversary if I pay no interest?
Then take the answers to two people. The first is a licensed insurance professional with years of hands-on experience servicing participating policies used for financing, who can read the loan provisions with you. In Quebec, that professional is a Financial Security Advisor (conseiller en sécurité financière); in other provinces, a licensed life insurance agent. The second is an accountant who understands the adjusted cost basis and the tax treatment of policy loans under section 148, who can tell you what a loan or a lapse would mean for your return.
I should be plain about my own position: I am paid by insurer commissions when a policy is bought. That is a conflict of interest, and it is one more reason this page asks you to verify everything in writing rather than take a slide, or my word, for it.
What this page will not tell you
It will not quote any insurer's loan rate, dividend scale or cash value, because each belongs to one contract on one date and each can change. It will not tell you how your own contract calculates loan interest or values between anniversaries; only the contract and the insurer can confirm that.
It will not tell you whether a policy loan is the right way to pay for your next purchase. That depends on your income, your contract, your other choices and your plan to repay. And it will not tell you how a loan, a repayment or a lapse would be reported for tax; that is for the insurer and your accountant to confirm.
Who this does not suit
Borrowing against a participating policy does not suit a family that plans to leave the interest unpaid for years, or that sees the loan as free because the policy keeps growing. It does not suit an owner whose contract is young and whose cash value is still small compared with the premiums paid. And it does not suit anyone whose plan only works if dividends stay at today's scale.
It suits families who need permanent coverage, who keep the premium and the extra deposit option going year after year, and who treat every policy loan as a debt with a repayment date. For them, the policy is a source of financing they control. The daily comparison adds nothing to that, and the honest one adds a great deal.
Important Disclosure: This page is for general information and education only and is not personalized insurance, financial, tax or legal advice. Participating whole life insurance is an insurance product, not an investment. The guarantees described are contractual guarantees of the issuing insurer and depend on its financial strength; they are not government guarantees. Dividends are not guaranteed and are declared each year by the insurer's board based on the results of the participating account. A policy loan is a debt to the insurer that accrues interest and reduces the net cash value and the net death benefit until it is repaid; under most contracts, unpaid interest is added to the loan at the policy anniversary. How values and loan interest are calculated depends on each contract. A policy loan is a disposition under section 148 of the Income Tax Act, as read on 18 November 2026, and can create taxable income above the adjusted cost basis. Borrowing against a policy is not suitable for everyone. The author is a licensed insurance professional who may earn a commission if you buy a policy.
In plain words: I am not telling you a policy loan is a bad idea. I use them, and I teach families to use them well. I am telling you that the loan has a real cost, that your policy's growth does not pay it, and that the right comparison is with your other ways to pay. Your contract, not a slide, decides how interest and values are calculated, and your accountant should look at the tax side before you borrow. And yes, I am paid if you become a client, which is one more reason I want you to check every figure in writing. The base of the policy is guaranteed: the cash value and the death benefit are written into your contract, year by year. The dividend is the part that is not guaranteed, and here the history is reassuring. Canada Life has distributed dividends to its participating policyowners every year since 1848, Sun Life has declared them every year since 1877, and Equitable Life of Canada has paid them every year since it began offering participating insurance in 1936. A long record is not a promise about the future, and once a dividend is credited to your policy, it stays credited.
If you would like to look at your own policy loan, or one you are considering, we invite you to book a free 30-minute discovery meeting. We will read the loan provisions with you, compare the loan with your other choices, and tell you plainly if borrowing does not fit your situation.
A thirty-minute discovery meeting
A first conversation establishes whether this fits. No illustration is prepared and nothing is arranged.
Often the answer is no, and you will hear it during the call rather than in a proposal afterwards.
This form reaches Canadian Wealth Creation Centre Inc. Any meeting, any advice and any insurance product is provided by Canadian Wealth Creation Centre Inc., through its representatives who are licensed in the client's province. IBC Financial is the company's educational website: it distributes no product and no financial service, and it gives no individualised advice.
Common questions
Does a whole life policy's cash value grow every day?
Is policy loan interest charged daily?
If my cash value grows more than my loan interest, is the loan free?
Does taking a policy loan stop my cash value from growing?
Why do some people say a policy loan costs nothing?
What happens if I never pay the interest on a policy loan?
What should I compare instead of daily growth and daily interest?
Sources
- Income Tax Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. 1 (5th Supp.), section 148, Justice Laws Canada, read 18 November 2026 (Act current to 2026-10-29, last amended 2026-06-18): subsection 148(9) defines a policy loan as an amount advanced by an insurer to a policyholder in accordance with the terms and conditions of the policy; the definition of disposition includes a policy loan made after March 31, 1978; paragraph (b) of the definition of proceeds of the disposition sets the proceeds of a policy loan at the lesser of the loan (excluding any part applied immediately to pay a premium under the policy) and the cash surrender value in excess of outstanding policy loans; the adjusted cost basis definition adds repayments of policy loans (element E); subsection 148(1) includes in income the proceeds of a disposition in excess of the adjusted cost basis., verified 2026-11-18
- Autorité des marchés financiers, How to access the cash surrender value without cancelling your insurance (English page, no date shown), read 18 November 2026: a policy loan must eventually be repaid with interest; interest accrues on the borrowed amount; if the insured dies before the loan is repaid, the insurer subtracts the amounts owed plus accrued interest from the amount of insurance payable., verified 2026-11-18
- Equitable Life of Canada, Policy Loan Questions and Answers for advisors, question 6, recorded on this site on 2026-11-03: a participating contract with a loan and an otherwise identical contract without a loan receive the same amount of dividend. Basis of the locked loans-and-dividends statement used on this page., verified 2026-11-03
- Dividend records: Canada Life Financial Facts, figures to 31 December 2025 (dividends distributed every year since 1848); Sun Life, Par legacy article, 17 December 2025 (declared every year since 1877); Equitable Life of Canada, 2025 participating fund highlights (paid every year since 1936). Read 2026-11-11 for this site., verified 2026-11-11
Last reviewed 2026-11-18. By Jose Salloum, Financial Security Advisor in Quebec. In Ontario, Life and Accident & Sickness Insurance Agent. In British Columbia, Life Insurance Agent.
